Case Study

“Hand-carried”, “Carry-on” or “Hand luggage” Goods

Avater User Author Bud & Prairie

Last update Aug 21, 2024

The client run a business on cosmetics and perfumes in Vietnam. Some of their goods were hand-carried goods. They were most concerned about how to sell these goods without breaking applicable laws. That was an interesting problem to deal with!

In Vietnam, “hand-carried” goods, also known as “carry-on” goods or “hand luggage” goods, are understood to be goods purchased directly from abroad and brought to Vietnam by air, often purchased by tourists, flight attendants, or a person’s relatives living abroad, or purchased and shipped to Vietnam by some service-rendering individuals or companies, etc. However, since they are not officially imported, hand-carried goods are often difficult to check the origin and quality, there may be risks such as buying fake or poor quality goods. Currently, there is no document specifically providing for hand-carried goods; however, some regulations are designed to control the quantity and value of goods that individuals can bring into the country without paying customs duties. The regulations are primarily intended to prevent smuggling and ensure proper taxation of imported goods.

  • Duty-Free Allowances:
    • Passengers entering Vietnam are allowed to bring a certain quantity of goods duty-free. This typically includes items like personal effects, a limited quantity of alcohol, tobacco, and some other goods.
    • The duty-free allowances for alcohol and tobacco are usually capped, e.g., 1.5 liters of alcohol, 400 cigarettes, etc.
  • Value Limits:
    • There is a limit on the total value of goods that can be brought into Vietnam without incurring customs duties. If the value exceeds this limit, the excess is subject to import duties.
    • As of recent regulations, goods with a total value of over VND 10 million (approximately USD 430) may be subject to duties.
  • Declaration Requirement:
    • Passengers are required to declare goods that exceed the duty-free allowances or value limits. Failing to declare such goods can result in fines, confiscation of goods, or other penalties.
  • Prohibited and Restricted Items:
    • Certain goods are prohibited or restricted from being imported, including weapons, drugs, and some agricultural products. Importing such items can lead to severe legal consequences.
  • Commercial Quantities:
    • If the quantity of hand-carried goods suggests a commercial purpose rather than personal use, the goods may be subject to stricter scrutiny, higher duties, and additional regulations.
  • Luxury Goods:
    • Luxury items such as high-end electronics, jewelry, and branded fashion goods are often closely monitored. Importing these items may attract higher duties.

Furthermore, due attention should also be paid to the following provisions:

Article 3.6 of Decree 98/2020/ND-CP (dated 26 August 2020, prescribing penalties for administrative violations against regulations on commerce, production and trade in counterfeit and prohibited goods, and protection of consumer rights), which stipulates as follows:

“6. “Contraband goods” include:

a) Imported goods included in the list of goods banned from import or the list of goods temporarily suspended from import as prescribed by law, unless they are imported with the Prime Minister’s permission;

b) Goods imported without the required import license or without meeting given import conditions as prescribed by law;

c) Goods imported without going through a prescribed border checkpoint or without following customs procedures as prescribed by law, or the information on quantities or types of which is falsified when following customs procedures;

d) Imported goods sold on the market without accompanied invoices and documents as prescribed by law, or with unlawful invoices and documents;

dd) Goods, which are subject to import labeling, imported without bearing stamps as prescribed or with bearing false or used stamps.”.

In light of the above provisions, hand-carried goods are not contraband goods if they meet the following conditions:

  • Not on the list of goods prohibited from import or temporarily suspended from import, except in cases where the Prime Minister decides to allow import;
  • Having invoices or documents proving the origin of the goods;
  • Hand-carried goods go through the border gate and go through customs procedures in accordance with regulations;
  • Having an import license (for goods imported under a license);
  • Goods have import stamps and pay full taxes according to regulations of law.

Selling hand-carried goods is a legal style of business when the goods sold meet all the conditions prescribed by law. However, in cases where the conditions are not met, this style of business will violate the law and can be considered smuggled goods.

Article 16 of the Law on Export and Import Duties (Law No. 107/2016/QH13 dated 6 April 2016), which stipulates as follows:

Article 16. Tax exemption

  1. Exported or imported goods of foreign entities granted diplomatic immunity and privileges in Vietnam within the allowance under an international treaty to which Socialist Republic of Vietnam is a signatory; luggage within the tax-free allowance of inbound and outbound passengers; imports to be sold at duty-free shops.
  2. Personal belongings, gifts from foreign entities to Vietnamese entities and vice versa within the tax-free allowance.

If the quantity or value of personal belongings or gifts exceeds the tax-free allowance, the excess amount or value shall be taxed, unless the recipient is an entity funded by state budget and permitted by a competent authority to receive them or they are meant to serve humanitarian or charitable purposes.

  1. Goods traded across the border of border residents on the List of goods and within the tax-free allowance serving the manufacturing or consumption by border residents.

Goods that are purchased or transported within the tax-free allowance but do not serve the manufacturing or consumption by border residents, exports and imports of foreign traders permitted to be sold at bordering markets shall be taxed.

…”

According to regulations, goods imported into Vietnam must pay taxes such as: Import duties, value added tax, special consumption tax, etc.

However, if hand-carried goods fall into one of the following cases, they are exempt from import tax:

  • Goods enjoying preferential rights and exemptions;
  • Goods within the tax-free luggage standards of people exiting or entering the country; imported goods for sale at duty-free shops;
  • Goods traded and exchanged across the border by border residents on the List of Goods and within the quota to serve the production and consumption of border residents.
  • Goods exempted from import tax under international treaties to which the Socialist Republic of Vietnam is a member;
  • Goods with a value or tax amount below the minimum level;
  • Raw materials, supplies and components imported for processing export products; finished products imported for attachment to processed products; processed products for export;
  • Raw materials, supplies and components imported for the production of export goods;
  • Goods produced, processed, recycled and assembled in duty-free zones without using raw materials and components imported from abroad when imported into the domestic market;
  • Goods temporarily imported for re-export or temporarily exported for re-import within a certain period of time;
  • Goods not for commercial purposes;
  • Imported goods to create fixed assets of subjects entitled to investment incentives according to the provisions of the law on investment;
  • Plant varieties; animal breeds; fertilizers, pesticides that cannot be produced domestically and need to be imported according to the regulations of competent state management agencies;
  • Raw materials, supplies, and components that cannot be produced domestically and are imported for production of investment projects in the list of industries and professions with special investment incentives or in areas with particularly difficult socio-economic conditions according to the provisions of the law on investment, high-tech enterprises, science and technology enterprises, and science and technology organizations;
  • Raw materials, supplies, and components imported domestically that cannot be produced domestically for investment projects to produce and assemble medical equipment that are given priority for research and manufacturing;
  • Imported goods to serve oil and gas activities;
  • Shipbuilding projects and facilities in the list of preferential industries and occupations according to the provisions of the law on investment are exempted from tax for:
  • Imported goods to create fixed assets of shipbuilding facilities;
  • Imported goods are machinery, equipment, raw materials, supplies, components, semi-finished products that cannot be produced domestically to serve shipbuilding;
  • Imported machinery, equipment, raw materials, supplies, components, parts, and spare parts serving printing and minting activities;
  • Imported goods are raw materials, supplies, components that cannot be produced domestically to directly serve the production of information technology products, digital content, and software;
  • Exported and imported goods for environmental protection;
  • Imported specialized goods that cannot be produced domestically to directly serve education;
  • Imported goods are specialized machinery, equipment, spare parts, supplies that cannot be produced domestically, specialized scientific documents and books used directly for scientific research, technology development, development of technology incubation activities, incubation of science and technology enterprises, and technological innovation;
  • Imported goods that directly serve security and national defense, in which specialized means of transport must be of a type that cannot be produced domestically;
  • Exported and imported goods to serve social security, overcoming the consequences of natural disasters, catastrophes, epidemics, and other special cases.

We must say that Vietnam has been tightening regulations around hand-carried goods to prevent tax evasion and control the flow of luxury goods into the country. Customs authorities at airports and border checkpoints enforce these regulations. They have the authority to inspect luggage, assess duties, and enforce penalties for non-compliance. According to the said Decree 98/2020/ND-CP, individuals trading in smuggled goods will be fined from VND 500,000 to VND 50 million, depending on the value of the smuggled goods. Organizations violating the trade in smuggled goods will be fined from VND 1 to VND 100 million. The fine will be doubled, up to VND 100 million for individuals and VND 200 million for organizations if the violator directly smuggles food, food additives, food preservatives, medical equipment, disease prevention drugs and medicines, etc. with a value of less than VND 100 million or from VND 100 million without being prosecuted for criminal liability.

For further information, please do not hesitate to contact us at [email protected].

Popular Types of Hand-carried Goods

Currently, there are many types of hand-carried goods sold on the market. Below are the popular types of hand-carried goods and are chosen by many consumers.

Technology goods

Technology goods are one of the most popular types of hand-carried goods today. Mobile phones, laptops, tablets, smart watches… are technology products that are often purchased from abroad and brought back to sell in Vietnam. When buying hand-carried technology goods, you need to pay attention to the quality and features of the product because hand-carried goods often do not have a warranty stamp from the manufacturer in Vietnam, so it is very important to check carefully before buying.

Shoes

Hand-carried shoes often have unique designs and are made of better materials than shoes made in Vietnam. However, when buying hand-carried shoes, you need to pay attention to the size and quality of the product. In addition, you should also carefully check details such as shoe soles, shoelaces, stitching, etc. to ensure the quality of the product.

Cosmetics

Cosmetics are one of the types of hand-carried goods that many women seek. Usually, hand-carried cosmetics come from countries such as: domestic cosmetics in China, Korea, Japan, the US, etc. However, when buying hand-carried cosmetics, you need to be careful because there are many fake and poor quality products on the market. You should buy cosmetics from reputable stores or ask the seller to provide invoices or documents proving the origin of the product.

Fashion

Carry-on fashion is clothing, shoes, accessories and other fashion items sold at a lower price than the regular retail price. These goods are usually purchased from stores in foreign countries, such as the United States, Korea, China and Japan. Carry-on fashion can be a good choice for those who want to save money when buying clothes and fashion accessories. However, there are also some risks when buying carry-on goods, such as counterfeit goods, defective goods and no warranty.

Other Accessories

In addition to the types of goods mentioned above, there are many other types of accessories such as handbags, jewelry, Chinese watches, etc. that are also sold at carry-on stores. Similar to other types of goods, when buying these types of accessories, you need to pay attention to the quality and legality of the product.

Distinguishment between Hand-carried Goods and Genuine Goods

There are many ways to distinguish hand-carried goods from genuine goods. To distinguish hand-carried goods from genuine goods most accurately, you can rely on the following criteria:

Origin

  • Origin: Hand-carried goods will usually have no brand or only a fake brand. Meanwhile, genuine goods will have a clear origin and be licensed to produce at reputable companies.
  • Certification documents: Genuine goods will be provided with certification documents from the manufacturing company, while hand-carried goods often do not have this document.

Actual experience

  • Time of use: Genuine goods often have a longer time of use than hand-carried goods, especially electronic products.
  • Product quality: With genuine goods, you can check and be sure of the product quality before buying. Meanwhile, hand-carried goods are often not checked and may encounter technical errors.

Warranty policies

  • Warranty policy: Genuine products will have a clear warranty policy and warranty support in Vietnam. Meanwhile, hand-carried products often do not have a warranty policy or are only supported by warranty in the country of origin.
  • Warranty value: For genuine products, the warranty value will be calculated from the new purchase price of the product. Meanwhile, for hand-carried products, the warranty value is usually only calculated from the repurchase price of the product, excluding other costs such as shipping fees or import taxes.

To avoid buying fake or low-quality products, you need to learn how to distinguish between genuine and fake products. For products such as technology, cosmetics, fashion, etc., you can find information about the product on reputable websites or ask for opinions from people who have used the product before. For products such as shoes, accessories, etc., you need to pay attention to the details as mentioned above.

For further information, see the Distinguishment between Hand-carried goods and Genuine goods?

Risks of Buying Hand-carried Goods Online

As you may be aware, many beauty products, functional foods, diapers, milk, etc. are being sold online as hand-carried goods, including brands with official distributors in Vietnam. The price difference between hand-carried goods and genuine goods sold in Vietnam is clear. This difference can range from a few tens, a few hundred thousand to a few million VND depending on the type of product. Genuine distributors are also facing great competition from “hand-carried” online shops.

However, buying hand-carried goods is very risky because there is no origin, no after-sales service, no warranty, no advice on usage instructions and no responsibility for health-related incidents. As analysed above, selling hand-carried goods is considered a legal style of business when the goods sold meet all the conditions prescribed by law. However, in cases where the conditions are not met, this style of business will violate the law and the related goods can be considered smuggled or contraband goods.

Selling hand-carried goods is considered legal if the goods meet the following conditions: they have been cleared through customs according to the procedures for luggage of people entering and leaving the country, as prescribed in Article 59 of Decree 08/2015/ND-CP (dated 21 January 2015 providing specific provisions and guidance on enforcement of the customs law on customs procedures, examination, supervision and control procedures); the correct quantity and type of goods are ensured when customs procedures are carried out; goods are not on the list of prohibited or temporarily suspended imports according to the provisions of law; goods are with invoices and accompanying documents and in accordance with the law on invoice management.Hand-carried goods are sold without invoices and accompanying documents as prescribed, and/or are not been cleared though customs procedures, etc. are identified as smuggled or contraband goods.

However, the inspection of hand-carried goods business activities still faces many difficulties. With the trend that online sales, products are often kept at home by the seller, the market management authority who wants to inspect these cases must have a decision to search the residence signed by the district chairman, but obtaining such a decision is not easy. In addition, many people who sell hand-carried goods often rent business locations, so when a decision is made to impose an administrative penalty, the violating individuals and organizations can easily escape.

Choosing to buy hand-carried goods means risks and disadvantages that buyers cannot control in terms of quality, even affecting health, money, and not enjoying warranty policies from the manufacturer. The taste for hand-carried goods and the foreign-oriented mentality have been thoroughly exploited by businesses to make consumers disburse. In the current situation of the hand-carried goods market being almost completely free, not only is it a loss of budget revenue but it also causes many consequences for society. Despite the availability of penalties, preventive measures are more important. Administrative sanctions are just a channel to limit smuggling and illegal trading of goods in order to prevent tax violations, thereby preventing loss of tax revenue from commercial activities. To deal with this situation at its root, it is necessary to synchronize policies from trade, market to tax, customs, etc. Obviously, the reality is in dire need of drastic intervention from authorities to protect consumer rights as well as the health of the market. Authorities need to strengthen inspections and checks of public services; resolutely and strictly handle violations. With the goal of protecting consumers, in addition to the efforts of the Government and authorities, it is necessary to have the cooperation of sellers, businesses and each consumer.

Avater User

Bud & Prairie

We offer a full complement of services in all areas of IP law, including without limitation patents; trademarks; copyrights; industrial designs; IP litigation; anti-counterfeiting and enforcement; and licensing, due diligence, and contract review. Our strong technique fields include bio-chemistry, biotechnology, pharmaceutical, superconductor devices and systems, civil engineering, electrical engineering, mechanical engineering, electronics, computer software, telecommunications, information technology, communications, media, construction. Bud & Prairie boasts a team of highly-qualified lawyers, licensed patent and trademark agents, engineers, paralegals, technical staff and legal professionals whose knowledge, experience, and acumen are second to none. Most of our attorneys and consultants own advanced degrees from both domestic and foreign institutions. We have the depth of experience of our partners with a perfect combination of knowledge, foresight and creativity, making us possible to analyse and solve issues faced by clients from various industries and providing them with all-round or holistic solutions that are not only legally sound, but also commercially sensitiv

                            

Advantages to Power

Our Borderless Teams

Expert & Experienced Team

Cost-Effective & Friendly Solutions

State-of-the-Art Technologies

Client-Oriented Approach

Network of 280+ Lawyers

Responsiveness & Flexibility